Brands shift marketing effectiveness focus from justification to learning

Brands shift marketing effectiveness focus from justification to learning

As brands dedicate more resource to marketing effectiveness they are looking to shift strategy to instill a learning culture rather than wield a stick.

Inflation is rising, interest rates are on the up and consumer confidence is on a knife edge, all of which means 2018 will be a difficult year for marketing. Media agency groups including GroupM and Zenith Optimedia have cut their growth forecasts, while the major agency holding groups are seeing revenue growth either slow or decline as advertisers, in particular in FMCG, tighten their belts.

Given this background, it is little surprise that companies want to better understand the return on marketing investment in terms of revenues and profit. That has led big brands increasingly to invest in marketing effectiveness. In an attempt to quantify this trend, the IPA spoke to a number of major brands – including John Lewis, Barclays, Unilever and L’Oréal – and found that three quarters have increased their marketing effectiveness resource over the past three years, with a third developing specialist units.

Although the IPA sample is self-selecting – brands willing to talk to the trade body about marketing effectiveness are likely to be those where this issue is top of the agenda – the study shows the trend towards demonstrating the impact of marketing across the business, says strategy consultant Fran Cassidy, who carried out the research.

“Effectiveness is about making an organization stronger, not just about making effective marketing,” she explains.

Direct Line Group head of insight and marketing effectiveness Ann Constantine explains: “The bottom line is it comes down to money. There isn’t the same [amount] in the industry as there was and everybody is watching what they do, how they spend their money.

“And the media world is changing in that there are a lot of digital elements coming in. People want to be able to know what they’re getting [from their marketing investment]. What is the bang for their buck?”

Resourcing marketing effectiveness

While more brands are setting up dedicated marketing effectiveness units, where they sit within a business differs. Some have created an

effectiveness unit within marketing, while others have it as part of an insight and analytics division or sitting under the commercial department.

Direct Line Group has had an effectiveness function for a number of years but it has shifted strategy over the past two years. Marketing effectiveness now sits alongside consumer, brand and comms research, and market and competitor intelligence within the insight function.

Insight is housed within marketing, reporting into group marketing director Mark Evans. The effectiveness team remains small – just four people with backgrounds in econometrics and analytics – though the broader insight function includes people with experience in market research, marketing and pricing.

“It’s quite a diverse team in terms of skill set and roles and responsibilities. We have got junior roles to quite high-level management roles,” adds Constantine.

Samsung is much earlier in its marketing effectiveness journey. Nick Milne joined the company from Telefónica in April 2017 to help set up a consumer analytics capability across Europe that encompasses marketing analytics and marketing effectiveness.

Milne says: “Samsung has a really proud history of product innovation but it’s no secret that innovations in the mobile sector are becoming incremental rather than substantial. If you aren’t creating as strong a product as perhaps you have done historically, you need to increase your consumer understanding – who are the consumers in the market, where do they shop, what do they like about their phones? – and follow that up with communications experiences that will help direct them to Samsung products.”

At Samsung, the team sits within insight, which is part of the marketing function, with Milne reporting into the vice-president of consumer market insights, who in turn reports into the CMO. Again, it is a small team, with one person looking at marketing mix modelling and econometrics and the other at digital activations and capability, but Milne is keen to improve its data capability.

“The amount of data Samsung has compared to Telefónica is completely different. And that is one of the reasons we were so far behind. Samsung needs to improve its data capability to then be able to understand what type of analytics, marketing analytics and effectiveness it can deliver. What I’m looking at is a roadmap to start delivering some of that,” he says. Diageo has taken an entirely different approach again. Rather than set up an effectiveness unit, Diageo created Catalyst – a digital interface that provides instant data to help its marketers make strategic and planning decisions.

Catalyst has dual functionality. First, it pulls together different data sources  to determine the right budget for each brand, based on potential profit and the performance of previous marketing programmes. Then it assesses the likely effect of planned activity, analysing short- and long-term effects and coming up with recommendations on where to shift marketing budgets on a week-by-week basis.

Andrew Geoghegan, global head of consumer planning at Diageo, says: “We saw an opportunity to use data and technology to massively increase the effectiveness of the significant marketing budget we have…. to ensure that every pound, dollar or rupee invested actually delivers the best possible outcome for the business.”

Creating an effectiveness culture

What differentiates Diageo is the scale of its ambition. Having launched the Catalyst programme 18 months ago, it had trained all its 1,200 marketers and senior executives across 55 countries in how to use Catalyst by the end of 2017, therefore instilling this focus on effectiveness across the business.

“Catalyst serves as a tool but what we’re doing is creating a culture and ways of working and thinking,” explains Geoghegan. “What we have done is enhance something that would be a core competence in every great marketer. The ability to turn strategy into execution is something that is enduring, but what is new is our ability to put micro-level analytics into that workflow and conversation.

“It has really enabled us to make small investment decisions right up to big portfolio decisions. And, of course, Catalyst is about culture, it’s about training, coaching and really developing this rigour and measurement muscle alongside the magic and creativity.”

Samsung’s Milne says that culture shift is the end game at Samsung too. While both Telefónica and Samsung started using marketing effectiveness as a means to justify investment, it is now much more about embedding effectiveness from the start.

“The business often doesn’t see [marketing effectiveness functions] as there to help but to tell them if they are doing their job wrong,” he says. “The transition we went through at Telefónica was that initially we looked back to see how things performed, but [that changed] so we were there in the process to help them out.

“It’s then about setting up the processes and the right tools and capabilities so [marketing effectiveness] should just be part of people’s roles.”

That is also the case at Direct Line. “[In the old structure], we were all about efficiency rather than effectiveness. We would evaluate our media spend and if we didn’t think it had performed in the way in which commercial said it should, then we wielded a bit of a stick,” Constantine explains.

“The way we have tried to reposition ourselves is by taking much more of a consultancy approach. What we are doing is bringing together our brand metrics, all our tracking, with our econometrics so we are really able to look through the [long- and short-term] lenses.”

Cassidy says this is key if marketing is to be taken seriously by the rest of the business as a real lever for business growth, and if marketing is really to become more effective.

“Accountability is the big issue. Being retrospective brings with it retribution if something hasn’t worked, rather than learning,” concludes Cassidy.

“Marketing effectiveness needs to move from a justification culture to a learning culture.”

17 thoughts on “Brands shift marketing effectiveness focus from justification to learning

  1. The advantage of one-handed opening to an outdoors person is of course particularly useful in and around water – if your arm is entangled or you are holding someone’s head above water and cannot release to enable two-handed opening.

  2. The things i have seen in terms of computer system memory is the fact that there are technical specs such as SDRAM, DDR or anything else, that must fit the technical specs of the mother board. If the personal computer’s motherboard is fairly current and there are no computer OS issues, modernizing the memory space literally normally takes under a couple of hours. It’s among the list of easiest laptop upgrade processes one can envision. Thanks for revealing your ideas.

  3. I precisely wished to say thanks yet again. I do not know the things I would have worked on without the actual creative ideas contributed by you over my area of interest. It was actually a real alarming condition in my position, however , understanding a new specialized strategy you solved it took me to jump for happiness. Now i am happier for this information and pray you realize what a powerful job you are doing teaching men and women through your blog. Probably you haven’t met all of us.

  4. I as well as my pals were actually analyzing the best hints on the blog and then at once came up with a terrible suspicion I had not expressed respect to the site owner for those tips. These men were as a result happy to learn all of them and have now absolutely been taking advantage of these things. Thank you for turning out to be considerably kind and for considering this form of terrific topics millions of individuals are really needing to discover. Our own honest regret for not expressing gratitude to earlier.

  5. I just wanted to post a simple message to say thanks to you for all of the superb advice you are giving here. My time-consuming internet look up has at the end of the day been paid with excellent facts and strategies to write about with my partners. I ‘d say that many of us site visitors are rather endowed to live in a fantastic place with many lovely individuals with beneficial tips. I feel quite blessed to have used the weblog and look forward to so many more entertaining moments reading here. Thanks a lot again for everything.

  6. I intended to put you that very little remark to help thank you so much again for your personal magnificent concepts you’ve contributed on this site. This is quite remarkably open-handed with people like you to grant openly exactly what most people could possibly have supplied for an electronic book in order to make some profit for themselves, principally now that you might well have done it in the event you considered necessary. These suggestions likewise served to be the great way to know that the rest have similar dream just as my very own to realize a lot more with respect to this issue. I’m certain there are lots of more pleasurable occasions in the future for those who discover your website.

  7. I enjoy you because of all of the labor on this site. Debby really loves engaging in research and it’s obvious why. Almost all know all of the lively way you give valuable tips and tricks by means of the web blog and in addition inspire contribution from some other people on that area of interest so our child is without a doubt being taught so much. Take advantage of the remaining portion of the year. You are doing a stunning job.

  8. Needed to draft you one very little word just to say thanks over again over the splendid ideas you have shown on this website. It has been quite tremendously generous with people like you to allow openly exactly what some people would have marketed for an e book to generate some money on their own, primarily given that you could have tried it in case you decided. The things additionally served to become fantastic way to be aware that some people have a similar keenness really like my own to realize much more with reference to this matter. I think there are lots of more pleasant opportunities up front for individuals that go through your blog.

  9. I wanted to create you the tiny word to say thank you as before over the awesome ideas you have contributed at this time. This is certainly surprisingly open-handed of you giving extensively what a few people could have advertised as an electronic book to get some bucks for their own end, most notably considering the fact that you might have tried it in the event you considered necessary. The smart ideas likewise worked to become fantastic way to be certain that most people have the identical keenness much like my very own to realize good deal more in terms of this condition. I know there are several more enjoyable sessions up front for many who look into your blog post.

  10. A lot of thanks for all your hard work on this web site. Ellie enjoys managing investigations and it’s obvious why. Almost all learn all relating to the powerful means you deliver valuable steps by means of your web site and as well inspire response from others about this concept then my child is certainly starting to learn a great deal. Have fun with the remaining portion of the year. You’re the one conducting a dazzling job.

  11. I want to voice my appreciation for your kind-heartedness giving support to individuals who need assistance with your concern. Your special dedication to getting the message all around became extremely productive and have constantly encouraged women much like me to achieve their goals. Your own invaluable advice implies this much a person like me and extremely more to my peers. Thanks a lot; from each one of us.

  12. I truly wanted to make a simple comment so as to say thanks to you for these awesome strategies you are giving out at this website. My considerable internet lookup has now been honored with useful facts and techniques to go over with my visitors. I would mention that many of us readers actually are unequivocally fortunate to live in a wonderful site with so many brilliant individuals with interesting concepts. I feel very fortunate to have used your website page and look forward to plenty of more thrilling times reading here. Thank you once again for a lot of things.

  13. Thanks for your whole labor on this website. My mum take interest in setting aside time for investigation and it’s really easy to see why. We all notice all of the lively ways you produce invaluable tricks by means of the blog and inspire participation from people on this theme so our own girl is now studying a lot of things. Have fun with the rest of the new year. You’re the one conducting a stunning job.

  14. A lot of thanks for all your work on this website. My daughter enjoys going through research and it is easy to see why. Most people hear all about the compelling medium you offer very useful tactics through your website and as well as attract participation from visitors on the area and my simple princess has always been becoming educated so much. Take pleasure in the rest of the new year. You are performing a dazzling job.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *